Word of mouth training regime led to warehouse worker’s 14 m fall
Friday 14th September 2018
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
Andrej Grzeszczak was working at Great Bear Distribution's premises in Desborough on 14 January 2016 when his vehicle was struck by another warehouse operations controller working in the same aisle. Grzeszczak's vehicle toppled and he fell, sustaining fatal injuries.
Great Bear Distribution pleaded guilty to breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety and Work Act and was fined £323,000 plus £30,000 costs.
Northampton Crown Court was told there was no electronic or physical system to prevent two vehicles entering the same aisle. Nor did the vehicles have sensors to alert drivers to nearby controllers. The operators' driving positions necessitated them turning 180 degrees to see through the rear window while reversing.
The company had failed to provide adequate training for its operations controllers, which the court considered to be a significant fault and directly causative of the accident because operatives ignored prompts on the computer system used to control vehicles that showed when one was already in an aisle.
Shirley Plenderleith, head of public services at Kettering Borough Council, which brought the prosecution, said: "While Great Bear Distribution had numerous health and safety policies and procedures in place, they had failed to recognise that their operations controllers were being trained by word of mouth rather than through a structured and supervised training process. As a result, a culture had been introduced which allowed a key safety control to be ignored.
"By ignoring a clear warning on the operations system that Mr Grzesczak's vehicle was already in the aisle, another vehicle was sent in and the collision occurred. This sad loss of a life is a clear demonstration to all businesses that proper structured training of all staff is key to a safe working environment for staff and others."
After the accident Great Bear Distribution, which says it "puts employees' wellbeing at the heart of its culture", installed a new version of the operations software, increased the number of CCTV cameras in the depot to 95, improved lighting on site, reviewed training and improved the visibility of vehicles and their controllers.
The company operates more than 7 million sq ft of warehousing space and an inhouse distribution fleet of more than 300 commercial vehicles.
The accident on 9 August 2017 occurred when a safety interlock failed, allowing the driver to come into contact with the truck-mounted auger conveyor – a rotating mechanism used to move semi-solid materials – while he was delivering wheat to a farm in Ripon, North Yorkshire.H Walton pleaded guilty to breaching reg 11(3)(c) of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations. It was fined £200,000 at Leeds Magistrates’ Court plus £531 costs.
During the nightshift on 22 January 2016, Leighton Jardine was coupling his vehicle to the trailer – known as a “wagon and drag” – which had been loaded with parcels and parked on a 3° slope at a depot in Brierley Hill, Dudley. The trailer rolled forward and trapped Jardine between it and the rear of the vehicle. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found safety arrangements for coupling trailers had failed to take account of the slope.
An employee of Northern Structures was removing roof sheets from a timber-framed farm building on 20 September 2017 when he fell through one of the asbestos cement roof sheets, landing 4 m below. A Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation found that, although Northern Structures had provided a risk assessment and method statement to remove the roof sheets from below the frame, the method was then changed so the worker had to stand on the roof and remove the sheets.
The 3 A Pub Company, trading as The Cross, pleaded guilty to breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act and has been fined £25,200 plus £5,900 costs. Environmental health officers from Warwick District Council found that the 18 year old had not received any safety training, information or instruction, despite having worked as an apprentice chef at the restaurant for more than a year. He had not been provided with the findings of risk assessments relating to work at height, use of fryers and contact with heat sources.
Basildon Magistrates’ Court heard on 21 September how the MD's mother, an Indulgence Patisserie employee, was asked to sort shoes, which were stored on a floor next to an unprotected area of fragile ceiling tiles when the incident happened on 8 January 2016.While carrying out the non-routine task, the employee fell around 2.7 m. The injuries she sustained resulted in a five-day hospital stay.
A waste operative for B&W Waste Management Services sustained third-degree burns when he was engulfed in a fireball created when a spark from a forklift truck ignited a cloud of gas from the canisters. He was put in a medically-induced coma for ten days on a life-support machine, has undergone several operations, and relies on medication for nerve pain. The forklift driver was also burned.