*UPDATE* ‘Man of straw’ lands suspended sentence for botched demolition
Friday 16th June 2017
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
The building on High Street in Ramsgate was owned by Panther VAT (PAL), a subsidiary of property investment company Panther Securities. It was an old textile printing factory with a historic frontage, but PAL had planned to convert it into 20 flats and had contracted sole trader Martin Elmes to undertake the demolition work.
After PAL's planning application was refused by Thanet District Council, the company claimed it had been advised by a structural engineer to demolish the building because it was structurally deficient. The council sent a building control surveyor to the site to carry out an inspection and he concluded that the building was safe.
Nevertheless, PAL agreed with Elmes to go ahead with the demolition. On 6 November 2013 both parties refused to obey Thanet District Council's instructions to down tools and a worker used the bucket of a JCB to knock down the building facade.
The council reported the incident to the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), which served a prohibition notice on PAL.
"The JCB just pushed the front of the building into the high street," HSE inspector Andrew Cousins told IOSH Magazine. "There was zero containment and masonry was flying everywhere. Members of the public were literally inches away from the facade of a building being pulled down. If just one bit of masonry had gone the wrong way, we'd have had multiple fatalities. It was absolutely appalling."
The HSE's investigation found that Elmes had not followed his own method statement, which referred to using a demolition grab to dismantle the structure.
"A demolition machine offers proper impact protection for the driver and has tracks for full control," said Cousins. "There were no safe working methods for dismantling the structure and no mention of hoarding off the area, which is an absolute basic."
PAL was also found to have requested a quote from another, legitimate demolition contractor, which had not accepted the job after discovering the work had not been granted planning permission.
The investigation revealed that the man who had asserted that the building needed to be razed for safety reasons was also the JCB driver and was not a qualified structural engineer. "If he's a structural engineer then I'm the pope," Cousins said of the man.
Both parties were sentenced at Canterbury Crown Court on 6 June. PAL pleaded guilty to breaching reg 4(1) of the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2007 for failing to ensure the contractor, Martin Elmes, was competent.
It was fined £160,000 after the judge determined that, under the sentencing guidelines, its culpability was high and the harm category was 1, moved up from 2 to reflect the "exposure of multiple people to a significant risk of harm". He set the fine at £240,000, reduced by a third for the early guilty plea. PAL was also ordered to pay costs of £9,129.
Cousins said: "PAL was set up as a separate legal entity in order to recover VAT on the construction works and owned the property, so we had to prosecute them only and could not take into account the resources of the parent company, Panther Securities. PAL is a micro company."
He added: "Everyone who has responsibilities under CDM needs to sit up and take notice. Just because a client may not necessarily have expertise in construction, they still have various duties -- one is to appoint contractors who are competent.
"The only reason PAL appointed [Elmes] was because he had put up some hoarding for them at another site in the past. On what planet does putting up hoarding mean somebody is competent to demolish a structure?"
Martin Elmes pleaded guilty to breaching reg 25(1) of the same regulations. The court was told that he was a "man of straw", had no assets, was claiming benefits and said his mental health had continued to deteriorate. The judge took this into account and imposed a suspended sentence, in addition to a four-month curfew from 9.30pm til 5am.
The site on Ramsgate High Street remains undeveloped.
The incident, which took place in September 2014, occurred only a year after a Health and Safety Executive (HSE) inspection identified poor work at height standards at the same site, and work was stopped until improvements were made. The HSE had found numerous openings in the first floor, through which anyone working in the building could have fallen several metres. Training for site workers was also found to be inadequate.
Canterbury Crown Court was told that the building on High Street in Ramsgate was owned by Panther AL (PAL), a subsidiary of property investment company Panther Securities. PAL contracted Martin Elmes to undertake the demolition work but did not confirm that he was suitable and competent to complete the task.
Weymouth Magistrates’ Court was told that employees of Carter Training had been using a mobile crane to lift a stillage of 500 2 kg fittings on a building site in Dorchester, Dorset.The container turned on its side and the contents emptied on to staff working directly below. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said that lifting equipment directly above contractors had put them at risk of harm. The victim, 44, sustained two fractures to her left shoulder blade, a fracture to her left collar bone, a cut to the back of her head and bruising.
The ministry said incidents involving vehicles were the most common cause of worker deaths. From January to May this year, 287 workers were injured in such accidents, six of them fatally. More than 250 workplace inspections will now take place over the next eight weeks in an enforcement crackdown named “Operations Roadrunner”. The MOM said that during the first five months of the year it inspected traffic management systems at more than 400 construction sites, storage yards, warehouses and factories. One in five visits uncovered poor practices.
Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court was told that on 7 January 2015 John Philbin had gained access to the Chapel Level residential development, for which Sandford Park was the principal contractor, through a gap in a hedge.Philbin, who had the onset of dementia, fell into the excavation, which had flooded with rainwater, and drowned. The site had been closed at the time due to bad weather. A ground worker found his body the next day.
The Old Bailey was told that Claxton Engineering Services, an engineering and service company that operates in the oil and gas industry, hired Encompass Project Management to construct a large pressure test facility (PTF) at its headquarters in Great Yarmouth for the high-pressure testing of pipes.Encompass contracted Hazegood Construction to complete the groundworks and build the steel reinforcing cage.