*UPDATE* Hotel lift crash injuries land Irish engineers with €750,000 fine
Monday 17th July 2017
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
RTÃ, the Republic of Ireland's national television and radio broadcaster, reported that five members of the Meehan family from County Meath were attending a cousin's wedding and were inside when the lift fell four floors and hit the end of the shaft. Three were seriously injured.
On 2 March, Tralee Circuit Criminal Court heard that Ellickson Engineering's installation for the refuge space safety system in the inspection pit at the bottom of the lift shaft failed to include critical components required to ensure a safe minimum space between the base of the lift and the pit. The lift could have crushed anyone in the pit carrying out maintenance work.
The omission came to light when the Health and Safety Authority (HSA) investigated a lift failure at the Killarney Plaza Hotel on 9 July 2011 that dropped the five guests about 5.85 m to the hotel's basement level.
RTÃ reported that Andrew Meehan suffered convoluted fractures to his left tibia, a broken right tibia and crushed right heel. His wife suffered a dislocated bone, which broke through the skin and was twisted at an unnatural angle. His brother suffered broken vertebrae and fractured left ankle and right heel.
The broadcaster also reported that it took up to 15 minutes before staff at the hotel realised the lift had crashed to the basement and the doors were prised open. There was no mobile coverage in the basement and the lift phone was broken. It took an hour before ambulances arrived and one of the injured members had to be cut out of the lift.
The HSA found Ellickson Engineering had installed the lift in 2004. The Irish Independent reported that the lift had special features for a refuge space so it could be safely maintained. However, lift specialist Simon Nicholas Lancaster had told the three-day trial that wiring, brackets and switches in the electrics for the lift had not been installed.
The company did not appear in court and did not send a representative. Director of public prosecutions Tom Rice said that, as a limited company, the case would proceed "as though the company had entered a plea of not guilty".
The firm, which is in receivership, was found guilty of a charge under s 10 of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 1989.
Brian Higgisson, HSA assistant chief executive, said: "All lifts when installed must have the required safety features included and those with the responsibility for the installation process must ensure that this is the case. The consequences of failing in this duty, as we have seen, can be extremely serious."
On 2 March, Tralee Circuit Criminal Court heard that Ellickson Engineering’s installation for the refuge space safety system in the inspection pit at the bottom of the lift shaft failed to include critical components required to ensure a safe minimum space between the base of the lift and the pit. The lift could have crushed anyone in the pit carrying out maintenance work.The omission came to light when the Health and Safety Authority (HSA) investigated a lift failure on 9 July 2011 that dropped five hotel guests about 5.85 m to the hotel’s basement level.
Sukhdev Kundi was working on a stepladder on the first floor of the property when the incident happened on 30 May 2012. As he was pulling cables, he fell off the ladder and through an opening, landing 4 m below.Kundi broke his spine in three places and was paralysed from the chest down. He spent three months in a coma and a total of 12 months in hospital. He died in May 2015, with the cause of death being respiratory failure due to a collapsed lung and pneumonia alongside his spinal injuries and paraplegia.
Two workers suffered minor injuries from the blast when Industrial Chemicals was operating the plant’s new hydrochloric acid (HCI) burner on 26 September 2013. Chelmsford Crown Court heard on 7 July that the burner had been used only a few occasions previously. The site had been under construction and was undergoing commissioning.
Taunton Magistrates’ Court heard this week that 26-year-old Ryan Sartin was repairing a roof at Home Farm, Shepton Beauchamp in Somerset on 23 June 2016 when the incident happened.T Broom Construction of Pine Park Road, Honiton, Devon pleaded guilty to breaching reg 4 (1) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005. It was also ordered to pay costs of £1,016.
Maxi Haulage had failed to implement control measures to prevent the incident from occurring and had not followed safe working practices.The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation found that, on 3 February 2015, an employee at the firm’s Cape depot on Cape Road in Warwick was injured when a piece of metal ducting, 6 m long and weighing 28 kg, fell from the top deck of the trailer and struck him on the head. The blow caused serious injuries, including a fractured skull.
Martin Gutaj has been sentenced to 14 months in prison and disqualified from being a company director for four years. He was found guilty of breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work (HSW) Act at the Old Bailey in London on 19 May. Gutaj’s company, Martinisation London, has been fined £1.2m after it was previously convicted of two counts of corporate manslaughter and two breaches of s 2(1) of the HSW Act.