Tesco’s £160k roll cage fine is eight times pre-guidelines level
Tuesday 7th August 2018
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 2 years old.
The difference between the two fines reflects the influence of the sentencing guidelines for OSH offences introduced in 2016, which were intended to increase sanctions on larger employers and the removal of a fine ceiling for magistrates.
The employee of Tesco Express in Chadwell-St-Mary, Essex, was working alone when the accident happened on 30 September 2015. The worker was using a tail-lift operated by the delivery vehicle driver to unload the roll cages that held the stock.
The worker was wheeling a 150 kg cage into the store when it lost balance and toppled on to them. They were taken to hospital with serious pelvic crush injuries and could not return to work for some time.
Environmental health officers (EHOs) from Thurrock Council investigated and found the store had ignored its own risk assessment, which required two people to work together while moving roll cages.
Tony Sprackling, the council's principal EHO and corporate safety manager, told IOSH Magazine: "This was supposed to be a two-person job, but it was custom and practice that the management moved [roll cages] on their own, as did staff. It was a local management failing."
The council added that, although Tesco had a system of work for the job, "it is plain [to see] that the plan for moving roll cages had been for some time divorced from the reality of experience at that store".
Tesco was found guilty of breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act. It was fined £160,000 at Basildon Magistrates' Court on 3 August plus £18,118 costs.
The company was previously prosecuted for a similar offence at one of its stores in Surrey in 2013. It was fined £20,000, then the maximum penalty available to magistrates' courts for OSH offences.
In May Tesco was fined £1.6m after a delivery driver reversed into a member of the public in west London, and it was handed a £116,000 penalty back in March after a worker with learning disabilities sustained a chemical burn to one of his eyes.
Sentencing guidelines application
Seriousness of harm risked:
Likelihood of harm:
4 with an upward adjustment to reflect the number of workers exposed to risk
Size of the organisation:
Starting point for fine:
Fine reduced to £240,000 for remedial action, co-operation with the investigation, had systems in place, good safety and health record. One-third off for early guilty plea
Although the team had activated the emergency stop circuit and assumed this would prevent the machine operating as work was carried out, they had not cut power to the control panel.The incident happened on 28 April 2017 when employees from Logistex were refurbishing the ASRS at the Shop Direct distribution centre on Linney Lane, Shaw, Oldham. The firm’s employee was replacing sensors on the equipment’s lift, which weighed around 800 kg, when it unexpectedly dropped around 1 m, trapping his foot between the lift and the frame of the truck on which he was standing.
Douglas Johnstone, 56, sustained a fatal brain injury while he was working at the Hinckley Golf Club in December 2013. Leicester Crown Court was told that Johnstone was believed to have been using a chainsaw to clear a heavy branch that had broken off a poplar tree during a storm and was lying in an unstable position across several smaller trees. He died alone at the scene and his body was found by a colleague the morning after the accident, on 28 December.
Birmingham Magistrates’ Court was told that the HK Traders’ employee had climbed up a scaffold at the company’s premises on the St Chads Industrial Estate on Brearley Close and walked onto the building’s flat roof without permission. However, the Birmingham City Council investigation into the incident on 20 January 2017 found there was no scaffolding. The health and safety inspector also found evidence to suggest the employee had been lifted onto the roof by standing on the pallet of a forklift truck.
The And So To Bed employee was standing on the platform, which was attached to a forklift truck and was open sided, on 1 February 2017 when the accident happened at the company’s factory in Bridport, Dorset. He sustained injuries to his knee and face, Poole Magistrates’ Court was told.The company was fined £113,000 plus £6,924 costs after it pleaded guilty to breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act and reg 3(1) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations.
The accident happened on 10 November 2014 on the Brent Delta installation, which has since been decommissioned and was removed from its concrete legs last year. Shell was fined £60,000 at Aberdeen Sheriff Court on 3 August after pleading guilty to breaching s 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act.
Kevin Scott, 60, was assisting a lorry driver with a blind side reversing manoeuvre at Tooles Transport’s yard on the Rushock Trading Estate in Droitwich Spa, Worcester Crown Court was told. He became trapped between the reversing vehicle and another lorry and died of crush injuries on 11 December 2013. Tooles Transport was found guilty of breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act and has been fined £150,000 plus £253,728 costs.