Golf course manager fatally claimed competence with chainsaw
Friday 3rd August 2018
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
Douglas Johnstone, 56, sustained a fatal brain injury while he was working at the Hinckley Golf Club in December 2013.
Leicester Crown Court was told that Johnstone was believed to have been using a chainsaw to clear a heavy branch that had broken off a poplar tree during a storm and was lying in an unstable position across several smaller trees.
He died alone at the scene and his body was found by a colleague the morning after the accident, on 28 December.
An environmental health officer from Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council investigated the accident and found Johnstone was not trained to operate a chainsaw, that he was not wearing a safety helmet and had been working alone at night.
According to the specialist magazine Golf Punk, the club believed Johnstone was qualified to use the saw based on information he had provided in his job application. Judge Martin Hurst reportedly criticised the club for failing to carry out pre-employment checks with the worker's two referees at Wentworth and Pinner golf courses.
The judge said the accident was a product of the club's "systemic failure to deal with health and safety" but acknowledged it has taken "substantial steps" to improve procedures.
Hinckley Golf Club denied three charges under the Health and Safety at Work Act of failing to: implement a safe system of work for the management of trees; carry out a proper risk assessment; and train its workers in the use of equipment, namely chainsaws, between January and December 2013.
However, the jury reached a unanimous verdict in May earlier this year and found Hinckley Golf Club guilty. Sentencing was adjourned until 27 July, when the club was fined £75,000 and ordered to pay a further £75,000 in costs.
The club is run by volunteers on a not-for-profit basis and has an annual turnover of £1m.
Councilor Kevin Morrell, executive member for environmental services at Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council, said: "This case serves as a reminder to any organisation run by volunteers that they have the same health and safety responsibilities to their employees as any other business."
The accident on 9 August 2017 occurred when a safety interlock failed, allowing the driver to come into contact with the truck-mounted auger conveyor – a rotating mechanism used to move semi-solid materials – while he was delivering wheat to a farm in Ripon, North Yorkshire.H Walton pleaded guilty to breaching reg 11(3)(c) of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations. It was fined £200,000 at Leeds Magistrates’ Court plus £531 costs.
The difference between the two fines reflects the influence of the sentencing guidelines for OSH offences introduced in 2016, which were intended to increase sanctions on larger employers and the removal of a fine ceiling for magistrates.The employee of Tesco Express in Chadwell-St-Mary, Essex, was working alone when the accident happened on 30 September 2015. The worker was using a tail-lift operated by the delivery vehicle driver to unload the roll cages that held the stock.
Manchester Crown Court was told that Riaz Ahmad had hired a group of workers, who had no experience in construction, to demolish a property in Oldham. A Health and Safety Executive (HSE) inspector visited the site on 11 August 2017 after it received a phone call from Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council’s building control department. The inspector found almost all the internal walls and roof supports had been removed and served a prohibition notice on Ahmad preventing any further work and closed a major road that ran past the building.
Birmingham Magistrates’ Court was told that the HK Traders’ employee had climbed up a scaffold at the company’s premises on the St Chads Industrial Estate on Brearley Close and walked onto the building’s flat roof without permission. However, the Birmingham City Council investigation into the incident on 20 January 2017 found there was no scaffolding. The health and safety inspector also found evidence to suggest the employee had been lifted onto the roof by standing on the pallet of a forklift truck.
The incident happened at the Maerdy Bridge in Cardiff on 15 August 2016. Kier had been appointed principal contractor on the Network Rail project, which involved building two new bridges using pre-cast concrete units.Newport Magistrates’ Court was told on 17 July that 42-year-old agency worker Peter Walker, who was standing on a ladder trying to remove lifting chains from a suspended 6.93 tonne block, was unsupervised. When an excavator boom moved, the block toppled over, and his leg was crushed between the fallen unit and the concrete block behind it.
Southwark Crown Court was told that Kier Facilities Services had commissioned leak detection firm JHH Engineering to locate and repair a leak that had been identified on a flat roof at Downsell Primary School in Leyton.While carrying out the work on 1 December 2014, an employee of JHH fell. He has been left with severe cognitive effects including memory loss and mood changes, and a reduced ability to care for himself.
A Belfast-based Risk & Compliance software provider has been collaborating with the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and construction giant Costain as part of an ongoing project to unlock artificial intelligence’s (AI) potential in improving the management of risks on worksites.
The tragic death of four-year-old Harry Lee on his family farm in Newchurch-in-Pendle has led to IOSH, the Health and Safety Executive, and Harry’s own family to call for a renewed focus on children’s safety in agricultural settings.
The owners and operators of the Holiday Inn Hotel in Hemel Hempstead have been ordered to pay almost £160,000 after the wooden staircase that a wedding party was standing on for a group photograph collapsed beneath them.
A SCUBA equipment supply company has been fined £9,300 and ordered to pay £11,000 costs after providing a diving school with contaminated air that led to children being taken so ill during a training session that one ended up in an induced coma.
The US Department of Labor has presented an Ohio-based vehicle parts manufacturer on its ‘severe violator enforcement programme’ with a fine of $480,240 (approx. £373,000) after inspectors found it had continually exposed workers to multiple machine hazards
The parent company of a contractor that was building a wind farm in Scotland and a security firm that employed staff to guard the remote site have admitted safety breaches after a security guard was trapped in snow for four and half hours and later died from hypothermia.
A care company that provides housing support services for vulnerable adults and children has been fined £20,000 after one of its employees was raped by a service user, despite concerns being raised about this particular service user for more that 25 years.
A care home worker who joked about reporting his employer to the Care Quality Commission (CQC) for not enforcing the wearing of facemasks at the height of the pandemic has won his claim for constructive unfair dismissal.
Chipboard manufacturer Norbord Europe Limited has been fined £2.15m after a four-week trial held at Perth Sheriff Court in Scotland found that a series of failings at its Cowie site in Stirlingshire in July 2016 had led to an employee’s death.