Gate engineer jailed for gross negligence manslaughter
Thursday 2nd November 2017
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
Automated Garage Doors and Gates employee Robert Churchyard installed the electric metal sliding gate at Jill Lunn's home in Blofield, Norfolk, in March 2013. It was designed to be operated both automatically and manually.
On 17 April Lunn attempted to shut the gate by hand when it failed to close behind her. However, a stop device had not been fitted to prevent it sliding off the track. It fell on her and she sustained fatal injuries.
A joint investigation by Norfolk Constabulary, Norfolk County Council's Trading Standards team and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found that Churchyard had not provided Lunn with an instruction book or operating manual for the gate.
In addition, a complete technical file, which demonstrates how the gate meets the necessary safety standards, had not been produced as part of the installation. Generating the file is a legal requirement and would have identified the safety deficiencies in the installation.
A simple "shoe" stop, or bracket installed at the end of the track for the gate to slide into would have prevented the accident from happening, Norfolk Constabulary said.
Churchyard had claimed that he had installed a stop and accused Lunn's family of removing it. This was rejected by the jury.
Churchyard denied manslaughter by gross negligence but was found guilty last month and sentenced to three and-a-half years in prison at Norwich Crown Court on Monday (30 October). He was found guilty of breaching safety regulations at a separate trial last year.
Automated Garage Doors and Gates pleaded guilty at an earlier hearing to three charges under reg 7 of the Supply of Machinery (Safety) Regulations. The company was also sentenced on Monday.
Detective Sergeant Darren Reade from Great Yarmouth CID, who conducted the police investigation, said: "If Churchyard had undertaken all the safety work expected of him then [Lunn] would have been protected from the gate breaking in such a way."
Trade association Door and Hardware Federation (DHS) said this is the first time an individual has received a custodial sentence for an incident involving an unsafe automated gate.
Its general manager Michael Skelding said the case "serves as a stark warning to everybody involved in the automated gate sector that they must ensure all doors and gates are checked for safety against current standards and regularly maintained by properly trained specialists".
Safi Qais Khan died at Master Construction Products Skips’ (MCPS) site in Birmingham after he became entangled in a poorly maintained trommel, also known as a sorting screen, in which waste is filtered as it descends a perforated drum. The machine was missing essential guards to prevent entrapment, it had no emergency stop button and was located on uneven ground that was strewn with waste, said the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). MCPS did not have a safe system of work for the trommel.
Newcastle-under-Lyme Magistrates’ Court was told that the Instrument and Control Services employee was moving the control panel on 2 February 2016. The unit, which weighed between 650 and 750 kg and was top heavy, toppled over and pinned the engineer to the ground. He sustained a pelvic fracture that split apart the left and right sides of his lower pelvis. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found the company had not risk assessed the task and had not provided a safe system of work or proper instruction and training.
James Hurst, a litter picker for Jack Moody Recycling, was collecting rubbish at the company’s composting site in Redhill, Telford, on 5 December 2014. He was standing next to a brick wall when the driver of a shovel loader drove over him, Shrewsbury Crown Court was told.The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said the driver was unaware he had struck someone and just thought he had hit the brick wall. He climbed down from the cab to inspect the damage and found Hurst badly injured on the floor.
Explore Manufacturing, which prefabricates concrete components for the construction industry, was fined £2m. Select Plant Hire, a supplier of transport pallets, was fined £1.8m.Nottingham Crown Court was told on 16 October that Explore employee Richard Reddish was working in a mobile elevating working platform (MEWP) in the finishing area of the company’s Worksop factory when the accident happened on 8 July 2014.
Howdens Joinery was prosecuted at Carlisle Crown Court after it pleaded guilty to breaching ss 2(1) and 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act. It must also pay costs of almost £34,000. The court was told that Richard Brown had been delivering kitchen worktops to the company’s premises at Clay Flatts industrial estate in Workington when the accident happened in November 2014.A forklift truck was being used to unload two pallets from the heavy goods vehicle when it overbalanced. It fell on Brown and he died at the scene.
Mark Goodge had been using an emery cloth to clean by hand steel shafts on the lathe at Marcantonio Foods’ factory in Barking, Westminster Magistrates’ Court was told.Goodge’s gloves became entangled in the lathe and his lost four fingers on his right hand, broke several bones in his left arm and sustained a dislocated wrist.The Health and Safety Executive’s (HSE) investigation found Marcantonio had no safe system of work for cleaning the metal shafts.
A Belfast-based Risk & Compliance software provider has been collaborating with the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and construction giant Costain as part of an ongoing project to unlock artificial intelligence’s (AI) potential in improving the management of risks on worksites.
In this webinar, we will take a closer look at what the new stats mean compared to previous years with a focus on the topics of chemical management, permit to work and EHS in the manufacturing industry. Book your free place now and earn CPD points, too.
IOSH magazine spoke to HSE inspector Bill Gilroy about a serious accident at a Nestlé factory in Newcastle – an almost carbon copy of a previous incident at another of the confectionary firm’s factories.
The US Department of Labor has presented an Ohio-based vehicle parts manufacturer on its ‘severe violator enforcement programme’ with a fine of $480,240 (approx. £373,000) after inspectors found it had continually exposed workers to multiple machine hazards