Brain injury sustained by warehouse worker in 4.5 m fall
Thursday 28th September 2017
From the archive: Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
The warehouse manager for Probus Creative Housewares, which is part of Germany-based Fackelmann and supplies goods to national retailers, was working in the company's warehouse in Cannock, Staffordshire, in December 2015.
The worker had used a pallet raised on a forklift truck to access the storage rack. He was standing with one foot on the racking and the other on the pallet when the pallet gave way, Newcastle-under-Lyme Magistrates' Court was told.
He fell 4.5 m on to the concrete floor of the warehouse and was airlifted to hospital where he was placed in a medically-induced coma for 11 days. He suffered brain injuries and is unlikely to be able to return to work.
Passing sentence, District Judge McGarva said "the incident resulted from long standing failures to improve health and safety, despite warnings from both the council and the company's insurers".
Environmental health officers (EHOs) from Cannock Chase District Council, which brought the prosecution, found that the risk assessments were outdated, inadequate and had not been carried out by a competent person.
It said poor racking in the warehouse, along with overstocking and lack of mechanical handling, created a "highly dangerous environment".
The council's investigation also found that the company's insurance provider had refused to renew its policy due to safety failings and a lack of compliance.
Aine O'Brien, Cannock Chase Council EHO, said: "Key findings of the investigation were: an overreliance by the company on individuals with no formal experience or competence in health and safety; considerable pressure placed on employees to quickly turn around deliveries and dispatch orders with minimal mechanical handling assistance; inadequate and unsafe racking; individuals placed in positions of responsibility with little knowledge or experience; and condoning of unsafe working practices by senior managers."
Probus pleaded guilty at the first hearing on 5 June to four charges.
It admitted breaching s 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work (HSW) Act, and regs 3(1)(a) and 13(2)(b) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations for failing to carry out suitable and sufficient risk assessments and not providing adequate training, respectively. It also pleaded guilty to breaching reg 4(1) of the Work at Height Regulations over its failure to ensure that the work at height was properly planned, supervised and carried out safely.
The company was sentenced to a fine of £240,000 with £20,000 costs.
Its managing director, Srdjan Urosevic, pleaded guilty to breaching s 2(1) of the HSW Act and reg 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations. He was fined £20,000 and ordered to pay £10,000 costs.
O'Brien said: "The fines were limited due to the company's size, though an attempt was made to use the recent Tata Steel case to financially link the company to its larger parent. Although the prosecution did not succeed in 'piercing the corporate veil' the company received no further reductions in fines even though it showed operating losses."
Sentencing guidelines application
Probus Creative Housewares
Seriousness of harm risked:
Likelihood of harm:
Size of organisation:
£2,500 (weekly income)
Starting point for the fine:
£160,000 per offence
26 weeks' custody / Band F fine
Early guilty plea, lack of previous convictions
Adequate cooperation with prosecution, lack of previous convictions, remedial measures taken to prevent reoccurrence
£80,000 per offence for three offences. Total of £240,000 plus £20,000 costs
On 28 October 2013 contractor Anthony Hopkins visited the Sycamore Road store in Rotherham, South Yorkshire, to replace the filters in an air handling unit on a plant platform above a suspended ceiling in the warehouse. He fell almost 3 m through the ceiling, sustaining fatal injuries.An investigation by Adrian Monkhouse, principal environmental health officer at Rotherham Council, found there were no barriers to prevent falls from the platform. The area immediately in front of its access ladder was only 45 cm wide and cabling presented trip hazards.
Explore Manufacturing, which prefabricates concrete components for the construction industry, was fined £2m. Select Plant Hire, a supplier of transport pallets, was fined £1.8m.Nottingham Crown Court was told on 16 October that Explore employee Richard Reddish was working in a mobile elevating working platform (MEWP) in the finishing area of the company’s Worksop factory when the accident happened on 8 July 2014.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) had visited family-owned Monoworld Recycling’s site in Northamptonshire several times in less than two years and served 15 enforcement notices on the company and three on each of the two directors.Northampton Crown Court was told that the company had not maintained work equipment, had failed to control risks from electrical systems, and had failed to manage work at height risks.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) visited two project locations, where In House Design and Build was the principal contractor, after workers and members of the public had raised safety concerns.It made several visits during 2015, Reading Magistrates’ Court was told, and served enforcement notices on the company for unsafe work at height, working in unstable deep excavations, and inadequate arrangements for planning, managing and monitoring construction work.
Merthyr Magistrates’ Court was told that machine operator Paul Dignam was standing on the control platform of a computer numerical control (CNC) milling machine that he was test programming. The machine’s three overhead millers and the linked control platform had started to traverse the horizontal milling bed when Dignam stepped off to adjust the cooling jets.
Martin Greenwood was working as a driver for YCT at Thurrock Parkway in Tilbury. He was coupling a HGV tractor unit to a trailer on 20 October 2015 when the vehicle started to roll forward out of control. Greenwood attempted to climb into the lorry’s cab to apply the brakes but was crushed between his vehicle and another, Southend Magistrates’ Court was told. He sustained serious injuries and died that day.