Home » News

Hospital’s poor patient protection leads to £333,000 fine for NHS Trust

Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust has been prosecuted after the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigated the deaths of five elderly patients and found a lack of fall prevention measures.

Hospital’s poor patient protection leads to £333,000 fine for NHS Trust
Image credit: ©iStock/Pablo_K

The patients, aged between 72 and 92, sustained fatal injuries after falling while in the care of hospitals run by the trust. Four fell at the Princess Royal Hospital in Telford; the fifth died of injuries at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital. The deaths took place between June 2011 and November 2012.

The HSE found a lack of close supervision of those in a confused mental state. Investigating officers found poor communication about the measures to stop frail patients falling had made the situation worse.

Mohan Singh, 74, was admitted to the Princess Royal Hospital on 15 June 2011. Staff were advised that he should have enhanced supervision, which involved bed watching. At about 4am on 17 June 2011, Mohan fell to the floor and sustained a bilateral subdural haematoma. He died on 21 July 2011.

After Eileen Thomson, 81, was admitted to the Princess Royal Hospital on 3 May 2012, she had three falls. Following the third fall a tomography scan revealed she had a subdural bleed. She died on 16 May 2012.

Edna Evans, 92, was admitted to the Princess Royal Hospital on 2 October 2012. She suffered a fall on 3 October. An x-ray confirmed a fracture to her shoulder. She was discharged on 24 October. She died at home on 30 October. Her post-mortem found that the injury she sustained from her fall contributed to her death.

Ada Clarke, 91, was admitted to the Princess Royal Hospital on 24 October 2012. Five days later, another patient saw she was trying to get out of her bed. A few moments later, Clarke was found at the side of her bed having fallen. She died later that evening.

Gerald Morris, 72, was admitted to the accident and emergency department at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital on 5 October 2012, having fallen at home. On 11 October Gerald fell while walking to the bathroom and was diagnosed four days later with a fractured left hip. He underwent two operations to repair his hip, but died on 18 November 2012.

At Stafford Crown Court Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust pleaded guilty to breaching s 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act. The trust was fined £333,333 and ordered to repay £130,000 in costs.

Vince Joyce, HSE’s principal inspector for Shropshire, said: “In different ways, these patients were left exposed to the risk of falling which resulted in their deaths.”


Nic Warburton is acting editor, IOSH Magazine

 Nick Warburton is acting editor of IOSH Magazine. He is a former editor of SHP and has also worked on Local Authority Waste and Recycling and Environmental Health Practitioner


  • It is sad when one reads

    Permalink Submitted by Tom Neilson on 30 November 2017 - 07:22 pm

    It is sad when one reads about people dying when they are being cared for by our NHS. What makes these deaths even sadder is that they happened to the elderly one of the most vulnerable groups in our society. The NHS are struggling to find cash to provide care for all sections of the community given that the fine will come from the public purse can only add to the cash shortage.

  • Another hospital where

    Permalink Submitted by Mike Flannery on 30 November 2017 - 10:23 pm

    Another hospital where serious failures in clinical care management are being prosecuted via HASAWA. Is this really what Robens and Parliamentary legislators had in mind in 1974?

  • Like so many cases, this

    Permalink Submitted by Peter Gotch on 6 December 2017 - 02:05 pm

    Like so many cases, this would be much more revealing if the defendant had elected to go for trial.

    It would then have examined whether or not sufficient resources were deployed to provide greater supervision, and whether or not it was reasonably practicable to provide such level of supervision.


Add new comment