Skip to main content
IOSH Magazine: Safety, Health and Wellbeing in the world of work - return to the homepage IOSH Magaazine logo
  • Visit IOSH Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit @ioshmagazine on Twitter
  • Visit IOSH Magazine on LinkedIn
Gender equality
Practice meets perfect
May/June 2023 issue

Main navigation

  • Home
    • Browse previous issues
    • Member accolades
    • Member tributes
  • Health
    • Mental health and wellbeing
      • Bullying
      • Drugs and alcohol
      • Mental health
      • Stress
      • Wellbeing
    • Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs)
      • Ergonomics
      • Manual handling
      • Vibration
    • Occupational cancer
      • Asbestos
      • Hazardous substances
      • Radiation
  • Safety
    • Incident management
      • Chemicals
      • Electricity
      • Fire
      • First aid
      • Slips and trips
    • Non-health related fatalities
      • Road safety
      • Work at height
    • Risk management
      • Confined spaces
      • Disability
      • Legionella
      • Lifting operations
      • Lone workers
      • Noise
      • Personal protective equipment
      • Violence at work
      • Work equipment
      • Workplace transport
  • Management
    • Human factors
      • Accident reduction
      • Behavioural safety
      • Control of contractors
      • Migrant workers
      • Older workers
      • Reporting
      • Safe systems of work
      • Sickness absence
      • Young workers
    • Leadership and management
      • Employee involvement
      • Management systems
    • Management standards
      • ISO 45001
      • ISO 45003
    • Planning
      • Assurance
      • Compliance
      • Emergency planning
      • Insurance
    • Rehabilitation
      • Personal injury
      • Return to work
    • Strategy
      • Corporate governance
      • Performance/results
      • Regulation/enforcement
      • Reputation
    • Sustainability
      • Human capital and Vision Zero
  • Skills
    • Communication
    • Personal performance
      • Achieving Fellowship
      • Career development
      • Competencies
      • Personal development
      • Professional skills
      • Qualifications
    • Stakeholder management
    • Working with others
      • Leadership
      • Future Leaders
  • Jobs
  • Covid-19
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Back to basics
    • Book club
    • Infographics
    • Podcast
    • Reports
    • Webinars
    • Videos
  • Products & Services
  • Management
    • Human factors
      • Sickness absence
      • Accident reduction
      • Behavioural safety
      • Control of contractors
      • Migrant workers
      • Older workers
      • Reporting
      • Safe systems of work
      • Young workers
    • Leadership and management
      • Employee involvement
      • Leadership
      • Management systems
    • Management standards
      • ISO 45001
      • ISO 45003
    • Planning
      • Assurance
      • Compliance
      • Emergency planning
      • Insurance
    • Strategy
      • Corporate governance
      • Performance/results
      • Regulation/enforcement
      • Reputation
    • Sustainability
      • Human capital and Vision Zero
  • Health
    • COVID-19
    • Mental health and wellbeing
      • Bullying
      • Drugs and alcohol
      • Mental health
      • Stress
      • Wellbeing
    • Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs)
      • Ergonomics
      • Manual handling
      • Vibration
    • Occupational cancer
      • Asbestos
      • Hazardous substances
      • Radiation
  • Safety
    • Incident management
      • Chemicals
      • Electricity
      • Fire
      • First aid
      • Slips and trips
    • Non-health related fatalities
      • Road safety
      • Work at height
    • Risk management
      • Confined spaces
      • Disability
      • Legionella
      • Lifting operations
      • Lone workers
      • Noise
      • Personal protective equipment
      • Violence at work
      • Work equipment
      • Workplace transport
  • Skills
    • Communication
    • Personal performance
      • Career development
      • Competencies
      • Personal development
      • Qualifications
      • Professional skills
      • Achieving Fellowship
    • Stakeholder management
    • Working with others
      • Leadership
      • Future Leaders
  • Transport and logistics
  • Third sector
  • Retail
  • Mining and quarrying
  • Rail
  • Rehabilitation
    • Personal injury
    • Return to work
  • Utilities
  • Manufacturing and engineering
  • Construction
  • Sector: IOSH Branch
    • Sector: Northern Ireland
    • Sector: Midland
    • Sector: Merseyside
    • Sector: Manchester and North West Districts
    • Sector: Ireland East
    • Sector: Ireland
    • Sector: Edinburgh
    • Sector: Desmond-South Munster
    • Sector: Qatar
    • Sector: Oman
    • Singapore
    • Sector: South Coast
    • Sector: South Wales
    • Sector: Thames Valley
    • Sector: Tyne and Wear
    • Sector: UAE
    • Sector: West of Scotland
    • Sector: Yorkshire
  • Healthcare
  • Sector: Fire
  • Sector: Financial/general services
  • Sector: Energy
  • Education
  • Sector: Communications and media
  • Chemicals
  • Sector: Central government
  • Catering and leisure
  • Agriculture and forestry
  • Sector: Local government
  • Sector: IOSH Group
    • Sector: Financial Services
    • Sector: Sports Grounds and Events
    • Rural industries
    • Sector: railway
    • Public Services
    • Sector: Offshore
    • Sector: Hazardous Industries
    • Sector: Food and Drink
    • Sector: Fire Risk Management
    • Education
    • Construction
    • Sector: Aviation and Aerospace
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Categories
  • News
Road safety

ORR road tests smart motorway safety claims and calls for improved analysis

Open-access content Nick Warburton — Tuesday 14th September 2021
From the archive:  Just so you know, this article is more than 1 year old.
Web-14th-Sept-Emergency-Refuge-area-Alamy-KETXHX

Image credit: Alamy

An Office of Road and Rail (ORR) report that provides quality assurance of safety data relating to All Lane Running (ALR) motorways supports National Highways claims that this type of smart motorway is relatively safer in comparison with other roads in terms of fatalities. 

However, the ORR’s Quality Assurance of All Lane Running Motorway data report also makes a number of key recommendations to enhance the data and evidence, including the need for a regular evaluation of the ALR motorways as more data or better analytical techniques become available. 

Road industry observers have welcomed the ORR’s independent analysis and agree that continuous monitoring and further evaluation is essential to achieve a more accurate picture of safety performance over a prolonged period of time. 

ALR motorways are one of the three types of smart motorways that have been in operation on England’s Strategic Road Network since 2014. The other two are Controlled Motorways and Dynamic Hard Shoulder Running motorways. ALR motorways feature variable speeds and the hard shoulder is converted to a permanent ‘live’ running lane, with emergency areas located at intervals. 

The removal of a hard shoulder has been a controversial move and safety concerns relating to this unique feature prompted a BBC Panorama investigation in 2020, which submitted a Freedom of Information request to Highways England and found that 38 people had died on ALR motorways since 2014.

Highways England was created as an arms-length body of government from the Highways Agency and has recently changed its name to National Highways. Its remit includes operating, maintaining and improving motorways and major A roads in England. The body has come under fire for its running of ALR motorways.

In February, National Highways was referred to the Crown Prosecution Service for manslaughter in connection with the death of Nargis Begum who died on a stretch of the M1 in September 2018 when her car, which had broken down in the running lane, was hit.

In response to concerns about the operation of ALR motorways, the government announced a number of measures to enhance safety in 2020. 

In addition, the Secretary of State for Transport Grant Shapps commissioned the government-owned body to produce a National Highways Progress Report earlier this year, which outlines how these measures have been actioned to date as well as how to fast track other improvements, including the use of radar technology to detect stopped cars in live lanes. 

When it published its progress report in April, National Highways claimed that fatalities on ALR motorways are less likely than on conventional motorways where there is a hard shoulder. 

In a further move, designed to provide an independent assessment of the conclusions drawn by National Highways, Shapps requested that the ORR carry out a quality assurance of the data and evidence that underpinned the progress report. 

In undertaking the analytical assurance, the ORR reviewed three key documents: Highways England’s 2019 publication, Smart Motorway All Lane Running Overarching Safety Report; the Department for Transport’s (DfT) 2020 publication, Smart Motorway Safety Evidence Stocktake and Action Plan; and Highways England’s 2021 publication, Smart Motorways Stocktake: First year progress report.

To strengthen the analysis further, the ORR also interviewed relevant staff at Highways England and the DfT to better understand the data and evidence that underpins the conclusions being drawn on the relative safety of ALR motorways. 

In addition, it reviewed evidence given to the Transport Select Committee’s Smart Motorway Inquiry in early 2021 and also sought independent advice from an expert econometrician to provide an external review of its own analytical approach.

Although the ORR findings concluded no errors in the underlying calculations, its report, published on 28 June, did note that there was ‘a limited amount of data available’. 

‘In 2019, there were only 141 miles of ALR motorway, the network having expanded from 29 miles in 2014,’ the ORR report notes. 

‘This means that only 29 miles of ALR has a full five years’ worth of data associated with it, and much less data are available for the remaining 112 miles.’

After evaluating the high-level statistics, the ORR also concluded that, although the comparisons about ‘the relative safety of ALR motorways were made in an appropriate way’, there were some issues in the tools that were used to underpin the risk modelling. 

For example, comparisons between conventional motorways and smart motorways ‘did not always separate the types of road’, which ‘may have obscured the impact of the removal of the hard shoulder’. 

One of the ORR’s key recommendations is that all sources of evidence should continue to be evaluated regularly as more data or better analytical techniques become available. 

Neil Greig, policy and research director at independent road safety charity IAM RoadSmart, believes that smart motorways need to be given more time before their safety performance can be accurately assessed.

‘They need to put the systems in place they promised such as the radar technology vehicle detection and they do need more data,’ he said.

Interestingly, Neil added that most of IAM Roadsmart’s members don’t like ALR motorways because of the loss of the hard shoulder.  

'IOSH believes that more should be done to protect people from the hazards, so any technological developments should improve road safety’

He pointed to a member web poll published in April that found that most of the 4,500 drivers surveyed expressed no trust in ALR motorways. 

‘Our members are predominantly experienced, confident drivers who have taken the advanced driving test and they know their way around a vehicle and the road and the results surprised me,’ he added. 

Of those who responded, 85% said they would want to halt the construction of smart motorways until the safety case was fully proven. Furthermore, 84% expressed little faith in the current systems’ abilities to detect them having stopped in the running lane if they were to break down and to protect them until help arrived.

Dr Laura Bradshaw, research programme lead at IOSH, said that all employers who have drivers on the road had a vested interest in improving road safety.

‘As work-related road traffic accidents are a significant cause of preventable death and injury, IOSH believes that more should be done to protect people from the hazards, so any technological developments should improve road safety,’ she said.

She added that only around 5% of the ALR motorway network had had the radar technology installed to detect broken down vehicles and said IOSH would like to see more research as well as the monitoring and evaluation of larger stretches of the network over a longer period of time.

‘The shortage of data won’t be resolved immediately and it presents a challenge,’ she says. ‘There have been calls to scrap the ALR motorways and have the hard shoulder available to improve immediate safety or failing that, to have more of the emergency lay-by areas put in at more regular intervals.’

The ORR acknowledges that, since the Smart Motorways Stocktake: First year progress report was published this year, National Highways has made further improvements to the safety of ALR motorways. 

The government-owned body has also announced further measures to enhance safety, including a soon-to-be published and revised Highway Code, which will include driving tips on how to use ALR motorways. 

‘Logistics UK is an advocate of smart motorways as an effective way to reduce congestion and produce more reliable journey times, provided high levels of safety are maintained,’ added Michelle Gardner, head of public policy.

‘Safety is of paramount importance to the logistics industry; robust data must be used to carefully assess their safety record and to determine any changes that are needed.’ 

You may also be interested in...

web_air-con_iStock-1151744289

 Employers must ensure workplaces are well ventilated to minimise COVID-19 spread

Thursday 16th September 2021
Businesses are being reminded that they have a legal duty to ensure that their premises have an adequate supply of fresh air in enclosed areas as part of a broad strategy to minimise the risk of the coronavirus from spreading via workplaces.
Open-access content
Open-diary-and-laptop-shutterstock_684787072

 Hybrid work benefits make it most popular model but risks must be managed, warns IOSH

Friday 10th September 2021
The benefits of hybrid working mean it is likely to become the most common employment model in the future but organisations need to ensure work arrangements are managed in a healthy and safe way, IOSH has warned..
Open-access content
web_man-with-arm-in-cast_credit_iStock-1146110842

 Global labour force has insufficient employment injury protection, ILO reports

Monday 20th September 2021
Little more than a third of the global labour force has effective access to employment injury protection, and there are significant disparities between high and low income countries, a global overview of recent developments in social protection systems reports.
Open-access content
web_semi-truck-on-highway_credit_iStock-530941654

 Concern about health and safety standards amid HGV driver shortage crisis

Friday 24th September 2021
A workforce that is overstretched and inexperienced will require training and support if health and safety standards are to be maintained, argues transport safety manager Dean Roscoe CMIOSH.
Open-access content
The Singapore government has revised safe management measures for employers to control a rise in COVID-19 infections in workplaces.

 Singapore revises safe management measures to prevent COVID-19 rise

Friday 24th September 2021
The Singapore government has revised safe management measures for employers to control a rise in COVID-19 infections in workplaces.
Open-access content
web_p12-13_News analysis_Pause-for-thought_CREDIT_iStock-1185417969.png

 Analysis: menopausal issues for women in the workplace

Wednesday 1st September 2021
A growing number of women in their 40s and 50s are leaving the workplace because they are struggling with menopausal symptoms, often in silence. Employers and health professionals must offer better support and education, enabling all women to flourish in their careers.
Open-access content
Topics
News
Road safety
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Latest Jobs

Health and Safety Improvement Manager

Leeds
£35000 - £50000 per annum
Reference
5452992

SHEQ Systems Advisor

Up to £40000.00 per annum + Car Allowance
Reference
5452988

Senior Health and Safety Manager

Reading
Up to £65000.00 per annum + Great Car Allowance & Benefits
Reference
5452983
See all jobs »

Sign up for regular e-alerts

Receive the latest news and features, free to your inbox

Sign up

Subscribe to IOSH magazine

Receive the print edition straight to your door

Subscribe
IOSH Covers
​
FOLLOW US
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
CONTACT US
Contact us
Tel +44 (0)20 7880 6200
​

IOSH

About IOSH
Become a member
IOSH Events
MyIOSH

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to IOSH magazine
Write for IOSH magazine

IOSH Magazine

Health
Safety
Management
Skills
IOSH Jobs

© 2023 IOSH • IOSH is not responsible for the content of external sites

ioshmagazine.com and IOSH Magazine are published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ