Skip to main content
IOSH Magazine: Safety, Health and Wellbeing in the world of work - return to the homepage IOSH Magaazine logo
  • Visit IOSH Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit @ioshmagazine on Twitter
  • Visit IOSH Magazine on LinkedIn
Gender equality
Practice meets perfect
May/June 2023 issue

Main navigation

  • Home
    • Browse previous issues
    • Member accolades
    • Member tributes
  • Health
    • Mental health and wellbeing
      • Bullying
      • Drugs and alcohol
      • Mental health
      • Stress
      • Wellbeing
    • Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs)
      • Ergonomics
      • Manual handling
      • Vibration
    • Occupational cancer
      • Asbestos
      • Hazardous substances
      • Radiation
  • Safety
    • Incident management
      • Chemicals
      • Electricity
      • Fire
      • First aid
      • Slips and trips
    • Non-health related fatalities
      • Road safety
      • Work at height
    • Risk management
      • Confined spaces
      • Disability
      • Legionella
      • Lifting operations
      • Lone workers
      • Noise
      • Personal protective equipment
      • Violence at work
      • Work equipment
      • Workplace transport
  • Management
    • Human factors
      • Accident reduction
      • Behavioural safety
      • Control of contractors
      • Migrant workers
      • Older workers
      • Reporting
      • Safe systems of work
      • Sickness absence
      • Young workers
    • Leadership and management
      • Employee involvement
      • Management systems
    • Management standards
      • ISO 45001
      • ISO 45003
    • Planning
      • Assurance
      • Compliance
      • Emergency planning
      • Insurance
    • Rehabilitation
      • Personal injury
      • Return to work
    • Strategy
      • Corporate governance
      • Performance/results
      • Regulation/enforcement
      • Reputation
    • Sustainability
      • Human capital and Vision Zero
  • Skills
    • Communication
    • Personal performance
      • Achieving Fellowship
      • Career development
      • Competencies
      • Personal development
      • Professional skills
      • Qualifications
    • Stakeholder management
    • Working with others
      • Leadership
      • Future Leaders
  • Jobs
  • Covid-19
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Back to basics
    • Book club
    • Infographics
    • Podcast
    • Reports
    • Webinars
    • Videos
  • Products & Services
  • Management
    • Human factors
      • Sickness absence
      • Accident reduction
      • Behavioural safety
      • Control of contractors
      • Migrant workers
      • Older workers
      • Reporting
      • Safe systems of work
      • Young workers
    • Leadership and management
      • Employee involvement
      • Leadership
      • Management systems
    • Management standards
      • ISO 45001
      • ISO 45003
    • Planning
      • Assurance
      • Compliance
      • Emergency planning
      • Insurance
    • Strategy
      • Corporate governance
      • Performance/results
      • Regulation/enforcement
      • Reputation
    • Sustainability
      • Human capital and Vision Zero
  • Health
    • COVID-19
    • Mental health and wellbeing
      • Bullying
      • Drugs and alcohol
      • Mental health
      • Stress
      • Wellbeing
    • Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs)
      • Ergonomics
      • Manual handling
      • Vibration
    • Occupational cancer
      • Asbestos
      • Hazardous substances
      • Radiation
  • Safety
    • Incident management
      • Chemicals
      • Electricity
      • Fire
      • First aid
      • Slips and trips
    • Non-health related fatalities
      • Road safety
      • Work at height
    • Risk management
      • Confined spaces
      • Disability
      • Legionella
      • Lifting operations
      • Lone workers
      • Noise
      • Personal protective equipment
      • Violence at work
      • Work equipment
      • Workplace transport
  • Skills
    • Communication
    • Personal performance
      • Career development
      • Competencies
      • Personal development
      • Qualifications
      • Professional skills
      • Achieving Fellowship
    • Stakeholder management
    • Working with others
      • Leadership
      • Future Leaders
  • Transport and logistics
  • Third sector
  • Retail
  • Mining and quarrying
  • Rail
  • Rehabilitation
    • Personal injury
    • Return to work
  • Utilities
  • Manufacturing and engineering
  • Construction
  • Sector: IOSH Branch
    • Sector: Northern Ireland
    • Sector: Midland
    • Sector: Merseyside
    • Sector: Manchester and North West Districts
    • Sector: Ireland East
    • Sector: Ireland
    • Sector: Edinburgh
    • Sector: Desmond-South Munster
    • Sector: Qatar
    • Sector: Oman
    • Singapore
    • Sector: South Coast
    • Sector: South Wales
    • Sector: Thames Valley
    • Sector: Tyne and Wear
    • Sector: UAE
    • Sector: West of Scotland
    • Sector: Yorkshire
  • Healthcare
  • Sector: Fire
  • Sector: Financial/general services
  • Sector: Energy
  • Education
  • Sector: Communications and media
  • Chemicals
  • Sector: Central government
  • Catering and leisure
  • Agriculture and forestry
  • Sector: Local government
  • Sector: IOSH Group
    • Sector: Financial Services
    • Sector: Sports Grounds and Events
    • Rural industries
    • Sector: railway
    • Public Services
    • Sector: Offshore
    • Sector: Hazardous Industries
    • Sector: Food and Drink
    • Sector: Fire Risk Management
    • Education
    • Construction
    • Sector: Aviation and Aerospace
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Categories
  • News
Health

Former soldier's appeal against damages claim dismissed

Open-access content Tuesday 14th April 2020
From the archive:  Just so you know, this article is more than 3 years old.
Soldiers in Afghanistan

iStock

A former soldier has lost his appeal against the dismissal of his claim for damages after contracting an infectious disease while serving in Afghanistan.

Between October 2011 and April 2012, the soldier was deployed to Afghanistan by his employer the Ministry of Defence (MoD). On return home he was diagnosed with Q fever chronic fatigue syndrome, an infection contracted while in Afghanistan, and was admitted to a hospital’s infectious diseases unit. He was later discharged from the army on medical grounds.

A medical intelligence assessment undertaken in 2005 for soldiers deployed to Afghanistan identified Q fever as an intermediate-risk disease. The MoD considered whether it should alter its approach to disease management by changing the chemoprophylaxis used to prevent malaria, but decided against it.

The appellant claimed the MoD had failed to carry out an adequate risk assessment and in doing so breached its duty of care. He argued the risk assessment should have led to a decision to change the malaria prophylaxis which would also have protected him against Q fever. However, the County Court judge ruled the MoD had continuously assessed the risk and its response was reasonable, therefore it was not in breach of its duty of care.

On appeal two main grounds were disputed. Firstly, the territorial application of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. The appellant contended the MoD’s failure had breached these regulations. However the MoD argued these regulations did not apply to activities undertaken outside of Great Britain. It was argued the judge should distinguish between activities undertaken outside of Great Britain and decisions made in the UK prior to those activities being undertaken. He claimed the decision by the MoD on the appropriate use of chemoprophylaxis against diseases troops deployed to Afghanistan may suffer from was taken by the MoD in the UK. This decision affected the health and safety of the MoD’s employees, therefore the MoD was subject to the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999.

The appeal judge ruled work activities undertaken by the soldiers were outside the territorial application of UK law, consequently the regulations had no application. It would be impossible for courts to distinguish between decisions made in the UK on activities of soldiers outside of the UK, and those made away in deployment. The activities themselves were undertaken outside of the UK so the MoD’s duty was one of common law, not UK regulations.

Secondly there was debate over the risk assessment and breach of duty itself. Q fever is a foreseeable disease for employees to suffer from so the MoD had to meet the standard which would be expected of a reasonable employer. The risk assessment for this disease and its potential effect on 20,000 deployed troops was different to a general risk assessment undertaken by an employer. The MoD’s 2005 medical intelligence assessment was as sophisticated a risk assessment as could be undertaken. It was detailed, comprehensive and adopted a global view of the risk to personnel from diseases as well as other hazards, demonstrating the MoD had not sacrificed employee welfare over its operations.

However an employer must continually adapt to changing information and evidence – so should the MoD have reassessed the risk and changed policy in light of additional information? The appellant argued the MoD should have considered the risk of Q fever in isolation, as the MoD was mainly concerned with malarial prophylaxis.

It was stated the MoD was entitled to take the fact the existing regime of prophylaxis for malaria was apparently effective and take a cautious approach and wait for more complete evidence. The judge ruled there had been an appropriate risk assessment, which was kept under review. Therefore the MoD was not in breach of its duty, and the appeal was dismissed.

This article was supplied by legislative experts Cedrec.

You may also be interested in...

Webinar

 Covid 19: webinar round-up

Wednesday 15th April 2020
IOSH Covid-19 webinars continue
Open-access content
Worker wellbeing during lockdown

 5 tips for supporting employee wellbeing during lockdown

Friday 17th April 2020
Mental Health First Aid England's director of people, Sarah McIntosh, offers advice on how to manage workers' mental health during the lockdown
Open-access content
Lone worker guide updated

 Working alone guidance updated

Friday 17th April 2020
The UK Health and Safety Executive’s guidance INDG73 on the risks of lone working has been updated.
Open-access content
Social distancing

 HSE issues social distancing warning to employers

Monday 20th April 2020
Regulator will hand out enforcement notices to those who do not comply with 2m rule.
Open-access content
HSA

 Legislation update for the Republic of Ireland

Tuesday 21st April 2020
The HSA has amended the welfare regs on the use of work equipment
Open-access content
HSE updates coronavirus guidance

 HSE issues new guidance on reporting incidents of coronavirus

Monday 6th April 2020
HSE issues new guidance on reporting incidents of coronavirus
Open-access content
Topics
News
Health
Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Latest Jobs

Health and Safety Improvement Manager

Leeds
£35000 - £50000 per annum
Reference
5452992

SHEQ Systems Advisor

Up to £40000.00 per annum + Car Allowance
Reference
5452988

Senior Health and Safety Manager

Reading
Up to £65000.00 per annum + Great Car Allowance & Benefits
Reference
5452983
See all jobs »

Sign up for regular e-alerts

Receive the latest news and features, free to your inbox

Sign up

Subscribe to IOSH magazine

Receive the print edition straight to your door

Subscribe
IOSH Covers
​
FOLLOW US
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
CONTACT US
Contact us
Tel +44 (0)20 7880 6200
​

IOSH

About IOSH
Become a member
IOSH Events
MyIOSH

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to IOSH magazine
Write for IOSH magazine

IOSH Magazine

Health
Safety
Management
Skills
IOSH Jobs

© 2023 IOSH • IOSH is not responsible for the content of external sites

ioshmagazine.com and IOSH Magazine are published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ